People are only now finding out what 17+ apps and rating systems entail; any application rated 17+ is refused the ability to have promotional codes generated, so you cannot send out review copies, etc.
TUAW writes:
Apple specifies that any application that may contain high levels of offensive language, violence, sexual content, or references to drugs or alcohol receive a rating of 17+. But, according to Apple, apps that feature an embedded web browser or provide access to 3rd party content also automatically require the 17+ rating, regardless of the application's content or intended audience.
Marco Arment provides a little more detail:
Assuming Apple applies their standards on what constitutes “unfiltered internet content” somewhat uniformly, this will affect, among others, any subsequent versions of:
Instapaper
Every Twitter and Tumblr client that can show others’ content
Every RSS reader
Every Flickr client
Every instant-messaging client (remember, text profanity counts)
Every social-networking client
Most ebook readers
However, it's worse than that.
If you set a rating for an application before you've finished it and uploaded to iTunes Connect,
there is no way to change the rating afterwards. So say, for example, you edit the application to remove offensive content or, as mentioned above, remove an inbuilt browser, you cannot change the rating for your application back to sane levels, thus preventing you from generating promo codes for it!
Until recently it was even nastier: If you had even a single 17+ rated application entry on iTunes Connect,
whether it had been uploaded/finished or not, you were forbidden from making
any promo codes for any of your other apps, even if they were rated 4+. I fell into that trap by having my (unreleased) Doom port listed on iTunes Connect as 17+; for months I was unable to generate promo codes for my other apps until I contacted Apple with a 'WTF?'. Fortunately, you were able to modify the rating at the time, unlike now.
I really hope Apple sort out this mess soon, because when the App Store system works it works really well.
I think a "o_O" is in order here. I have an application in development (airpoke.com - shameless plug, feel free to edit it out) and now I have no idea whether or not I'll have to mark it 17+ due to "3rd party content" or because I embedded a UIWebView for some reason.
ReplyDeleteThe worst thing is that I know that there is absolutely no reason that users <=17 shouldn't be allowed to use my app, but I'll have to mark it for 17+ only. To everyday users who aren't aware of what Apple is doing, it'll look ridiculous.